1968 Michael K. Seaton (CA) - National Commander by vote of National Convention body
1969 Robert McBride (OH) - National Commander by vote of National Convention body
1970 J.R. Stillwell (IL) - National Commander by vote of National Convention body
1971 J.R. Stillwell (IL) - National Commander by vote of National Convention body
1972 John Smolinsky (MA) - National Commander by vote of National Convention body
1973 Robert Faust (CA)
1974 James R. Hartman (MD)
1975 Gregory D. Reis (IL)
1976 Grant M. Jamieson (MI)
1977 Charles E. Gannon (MD)
1978 John M. Sherrard (CA)
1979 Richard J. Kepler (FL) - (Deceased)
1980 Ernest Wilson (NJ) - (Deceased)
1981 Donald L. Willson (PA) - (Deceased)
1982 David P. Stephens (IN)
1983 Christopher R Cerullo (NY)
1984 Fred L. Hartline, Sr. (OH)
1985 Woodrow L. Mudge (CO) - (Deceased)
1986 Royce Doucet (LA) - (Deceased)
1987 Douglas P. Bible (MN)
1988 Richard L. League (MD)
1989 David R. Faust (WI)
1990 Charles R. Belles (VA) - (Deceased)
1991 Robert A. Worrel (IN)
1992 Eugene L. Sacco (CA)
1993 Charles B. Rigsby (MI) - (Deceased)
1994 Roland D. Matteson (AZ) - (Deceased)
1995 Joseph M. Mayne (MN)
1996 John T. Dietz (KY)
1997 Jack E. Jordan (TX)
1998 William E. Matoska (MD)
1999 Byron J. Robichaux (LA)
2000 Richard L. Cook (OK)
2001 Kevin N. Winkelmann (TX)
2002 Clifford A. Smith (MA)
2003 Steve C. Laws (NC) - (Deceased)
2004 Neal C. Warnken (KS)
2005 Michael J. Deacon (IA)
2006 William L. Sparwasser (MD)
2007 Earl R. Ruttkofsky (MI)
2008 Raymond P. Giehll, Jr. (IN)
2009 Patrick J. Shea (OH) - Honorary - (Deceased)
2009 Thomas E. Cisna (IL)
2010 Mark E. Arneson (GA)
2011 David L. Dew (TX)
2012 James K. Roberts, III (FL)
2013 Christopher J. Huntzinger (PA) - (Deceased)
2014 Joseph W. Gladden (MD)
2015 Michael W. Moss (CO)
2016 Kevin L. Collier (AK)
2017 Brian J. O’Hearne (MA) - National Commander by vote of National Convention body
2017 Jeff C. Frain (AZ)
2018 Danny J. Smith (NE)
2019 Greg K. “Doc” Gibbs (NY)
2020 Clint D. Bolt (VA)
2021 Clint D. Bolt (VA)
2022 Joseph Paviglianti (NY) - National Commander by vote of National Convention body
2022 Michael Fox (CA)
2023 Christopher Carlton (IN)